A-State Rugby has a long-standing tradition of having players selected as All-Americans. Below is a list of A-State players on the 15s and 7s All-American squads.
15s All-American
- Pichant, Yves (2000)
- Huckaby, Matt (2001, 2002)
- Albury, Jarvis (2005, 2006)
- Graves, Doug (2005)
- Evans, Roland (2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011)
- Grubbs, Jake (2008)
- Caswell, David (2010)
- Farr, Roan (2010,2011)
- Wessels, Nardus (2010, 2011)
- Potgeiter, Shaun (2011, 2012, 2013, 2014)
- Sullivan, Pat (2011, 2012)
- Mizell, Zac (2012, 2013)
- Paterson, Sean (2012, 2013)
- Gericke, Dean (2013)
- Cook, Connor (2014)
- Higgins, Harry (2014)
15s All-American Honorable Mention
- Huckaby, Curtis (2005)
- Turner, Jack, (2005)
- Farr, Roan (2009)
- Wessels, Nardus (2009)
- Wittier, Clint (2009)
- Caswell, David (2010)
- Potgeiter, Shaun (2010)
- Sullivan, Pat (2010)
- Swanepoel, Danie (2011)
- Benade, Paul (2012, 2014)
- Gericke, Dean (2012)
- Mizell, Jake (2012)
- Pretorius, Kirk (2013, 2015)
- Brown, Gavin (2014)
- Makuvire, Kudakwashe (2015)
7s All-American
- Benade, Paul (2012)
- Mizell, Zac (2012, 2013)
- Swanepoel, Danie (2012)
- Carrion, Dylan (2013, 2014, 2015)
- Elan-Puttick, Robert (2013, 2014)
- Gericke, Dean (2013)
- Potgieter, Shaun (2013)
- Hausser, Tom (2014, 2015)
7s All-American Honorable Mention
- Potgeiter, Shaun (2012, 2014)
- Benade, Paul (2013)
7s All Tournament Team (2012)
- Carrion, Dylan (2nd Team)
- Elan-Puttick, Robert
- Gericke, Dean
- Mizell, Zac (MVP)
- Potgeiter, Shaun
